Island Fish

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.6

( 8 reviews )

Specialty Food, Seafood Markets $$

Closed 11:00 AM - 07:00 PM See Hours

655 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, NY 11738, United States

+1 6316-987-700

Island Fish is a brand that specializes in providing high-quality seafood to its customers. With a passion for marine cuisine, Island Fish aims to bring the flavors of the ocean to your plate. Offering a wide selection of seafood options, including lobster bisque, shrimp, salmon, and more, they ensure that every dish is cooked to perfection. Whether you're in the mood for a quick takeout or a sit-down meal, Island Fish has got you covered. Their commitment to sourcing fresh ingredients and delivering exceptional service sets them apart from the competition. With glowing reviews and a loyal customer base, Island Fish has established itself as a go-to destination for seafood lovers. Explore their menu and experience the taste of the sea at Island Fish.

Reviews

4.6/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Cam kasper

March 22, 2024

The young gentlemen who helped me yesterday were not only knowledgeable of all their products they were so nice and made me feel welcome. Service with a smile and answered every question. Definitely will be back. Great food , fresh fish , great prices. Shrimps were big and really delicious. Calamari off the hook and fish cakes tasted like my Mom used to make. Can't wait to get them again next week . Give this place a try. You won't be sorry 10 stars Went back for NY Eve bought Crab and Shrimp Cakes they were the best we have ever tasted. Full big pieces of crab and Shrimp in the cakes. Once again best fish, Best Service and Employees . Will be back . Well we are back August 2023 First grocery stop Island Fish Crab cakes and Fish Cakes 100 % perfection. Be back next week for salmon and more fish cakes , they were so tender and fried up perfectly. Love love love. Best fish market in Long Island. September 1, 2023 Fish Cakes and Salmon Absolutely phenomenal. Best Fish in all Long Island . Fresh and delicious. Going back this Friday. Yummmmo 10 stars 🌟 Sept 29 ,2023 Bought Fish Cakes and Potato and Cheese Croquettes they were devoured in two minutes . THE MOST DELICIOUS FISH , WEVE EVER EATEN. BE BACK NEXT WEEK FOR MORE.

Family v

March 22, 2024

The food was amazing. I spoke with the person up front and said I wanted to try a bit of everything. We picked out the seafood and they put it all together. Staff was super friendly and accommodating. Food was delicious. Service was amazing. The place was clean and presentable. 10/10, highly recommend

Kristin williams

March 22, 2024

We went here to buy fresh fish. Most of the fish were in refrigerator glass cases and looked old and not fresh. I did buy a piece of salmon and it was not bad but not the freshest. We did buy a bowl of spicy crab soup that was really good. Prices were high and quality was low. Would not go back there at all. Looks like they specialize in cooked seafood. They had many selections of fried or baked seafood in refrigerated cases.

Joe rifi

March 22, 2024

We came in because the reviews seemed good , we got 95 dollars worth of lobster tails which were frozen , they must have been there for quite some time . When defrosted they had a strong seafood odor. And after cooked they were not good at all . Extremely disappointed will not return

Ben kirby

March 22, 2024

This is a little hidden gem, that is always serving fantastic products and customer service…. The staff is very personable and the food is excellent… I highly recommend Island Fish

Lee gormley

March 22, 2024

Went to this fish market to purchase lobsters and scallops. The wait staff was excellent.! He made AWESOME suggestions! Thanks for even letting me sample fresh made dry sea scallops!! They were amazing! See you guys soon for more delicious seafood! Here is a pic of my end RESULT!😋😋 …

Fred mock

March 22, 2024

Incredible food! Extremely friendly staff. Offered us food samples before we even ordered. Shrimp and dill was the best shrimp I’ve ever had. The lobster bisque was absolutely amazing. The scallops were cooked to perfection. This little spot is the best hidden gem in this area. Oh…and the seafood market? Best prices. They do it right. They know what they’re doing. They explain everything to you and how it’s priced and believe me, it’s priced to your benefit. Not theirs.